
10 Rental Car Scams You Should Be Aware of in the U.S.
When renting a car in the U.S., most travelers expect a smooth process — but unfortunately, rental car scams are a real issue. Whether you're renting a car for business, vacation, or a weekend getaway, it's important to be aware of common scams that could end up costing you more than you bargained for. In this article, we'll explore 10 rental car scams you should be aware of and how to avoid them, ensuring that your trip goes off without a hitch.
- 1. Excessive Charges for Damages
- 2. The “Full Tank” Fuel Scam
- 3. Upgraded Model Scam
- 4. Hidden Extra Fees
- 5. Late Return Fees
- 6. The Extra Insurance Scam
- 7. The “Additional Drivers” Scam
- 8. Cleaning Fees Scam
- 9. Unnecessary Upgrades
- 10. Prepaid Rentals with No Refund
1. Excessive Charges for Damages
One of the most common rental car scams involves excessive charges for damages to the car. Sometimes, these damages are either exaggerated or completely fabricated. Rental agencies might claim that the car has scratches or dents that were not there when you picked up the vehicle, and then charge you for the repairs.

Hertz Car Rental - Salem - South Broadway
SalemRockingham CountyNew Hampshire
488 S Broadway, Salem, NH 03079, USA
1.1 How to Avoid This Scam
To avoid falling victim to this scam, always take photos or videos of the car when you pick it up. Document any existing damages and have the rental agent sign off on them. When you return the car, do a walk-around with the agent and ask them to confirm that no new damages occurred during your rental.
2. The “Full Tank” Fuel Scam
Many rental companies offer a "full tank" of fuel when you pick up the car, but the catch is that they charge you a premium rate for the fuel. If you don't return the car with a full tank, they charge you for the remaining fuel at a much higher price than local gas stations.
2.1 How to Avoid This Scam
Always fill the car up with gas before returning it. Check the fuel level before you leave the rental lot, and make sure to note the fuel gauge when you return the car. If the rental agency offers a prepaid fuel option, it's often better to decline it unless you are absolutely certain that you won't be able to fill up before returning the vehicle.
3. Upgraded Model Scam
Another common scam is when rental companies "upgrade" you to a more expensive vehicle and then charge you for the upgrade. This often happens when you arrive at the rental location and they claim that the car you reserved is not available. They may offer a "free upgrade" to a higher-end model, but you’ll end up paying more for it.
3.1 How to Avoid This Scam
To avoid this scam, always confirm your reservation details when you book and when you pick up the car. If the car you reserved isn't available, ask for a similar model at the same price or demand a discount on the upgraded vehicle.
4. Hidden Extra Fees
Rental companies sometimes hide extra fees that can significantly increase the total cost of your rental. These may include charges for things like additional driver fees, late-night pick-up fees, airport surcharges, or charges for using certain types of roads.
4.1 How to Avoid This Scam
Always read the terms and conditions before booking, and ask the rental company about any potential extra fees. Make sure you understand the full cost of your rental, including any taxes and additional charges that might apply. If you’re picking up the car at an airport, be aware that rental agencies often charge higher fees for airport pick-ups.
5. Late Return Fees
Some rental agencies impose steep fees if you return the car even a few minutes late. These late fees can be unreasonable and often aren't clearly communicated at the time of booking.
5.1 How to Avoid This Scam
To avoid late return fees, be sure to return the car within the agreed-upon time. If you’re going to be late, contact the rental agency as soon as possible to inform them. Some companies may allow a grace period, but it’s best to be punctual to avoid unexpected fees.
6. The Extra Insurance Scam
Rental car companies often try to sell you additional insurance coverage that you don’t need. While insurance is important, the coverage they offer may overlap with your personal car insurance or credit card benefits, meaning you could be paying for coverage you already have.
6.1 How to Avoid This Scam
Check with your own car insurance provider and your credit card company before renting a car to find out what coverage you’re already entitled to. If you’re already covered, politely decline the extra insurance from the rental agency.
7. The “Additional Drivers” Scam
Many rental car companies charge a fee for adding an additional driver to the rental agreement. While this fee is often disclosed, some companies will try to sneak in additional charges, claiming the driver is not listed or was not authorized.
7.1 How to Avoid This Scam
Make sure that all additional drivers are listed in your rental agreement, and that you’ve paid the proper fee. Always ask about the policy for additional drivers before you sign the rental agreement.
8. Cleaning Fees Scam
Some rental agencies charge hefty cleaning fees for cars that are returned with minor dirt or mess. This is especially common if you’re renting a vehicle in a tourist area or after a long road trip.
8.1 How to Avoid This Scam
To avoid cleaning fees, keep the car as clean as possible during your rental. Make sure to remove all personal items and trash before returning the car, and check the vehicle for any dirt or debris.
9. Unnecessary Upgrades
Rental car companies may try to upsell you on upgrades like a GPS system, satellite radio, or car seat, even when you don’t need them. These upgrades come with additional charges, even if you don’t plan to use them.
9.1 How to Avoid This Scam
When you pick up your rental, clearly state what you need and decline any unnecessary add-ons. If you have your own GPS or don’t need a car seat, let the rental agent know upfront.
10. Prepaid Rentals with No Refund
Some rental companies offer prepaid rentals at a discounted rate, but if you need to cancel or change your reservation, you might find that there’s no refund available.
10.1 How to Avoid This Scam
If you choose a prepaid rental, be sure to read the cancellation policy carefully. In some cases, it may be better to pay a little more for a rental that offers more flexible terms, especially if your travel plans are uncertain.
By being aware of these 10 common rental car scams, you can avoid falling victim to unfair practices. Make sure to do your research, read the fine print, and ask questions when booking your rental. For a hassle-free car rental experience, visit LifeStar Car Rental and find the best deals on rental cars without the hidden fees.








Hertz Car Rental - San Clemente - Via Pico Plaza3.0 (60 reviews)
Enterprise Rent-A-Car3.0 (262 reviews)
Rent-A-Wreck of Newark Local1.0 (17 reviews)
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (288 reviews)
U-Haul rental0.0 (0 reviews)
LUX LUXURY RENTAL5.0 (5 reviews)
What Rental Car Companies Don’t Tell You About Insurance Coverage
Best Ways to Split Rental Car Costs Among Group Travelers
Why Booking Through Aggregator Websites Can Sometimes Backfire
How to Avoid Paying for Optional Equipment You Don’t Need in a Rental Car
How to Handle a Delayed or Canceled Flight When Your Rental Car Booking is Affected
How to Rent a Car as a Young Driver in the U.S.: Age Restrictions & Cost Tips