Priceless Car Rental Introduce
For Connecticut residents and visitors seeking an affordable and straightforward car rental experience near the New Haven area, Priceless Car Rental in East Haven provides a local, value-focused option. Conveniently situated on Foxon Road, this agency is strategically positioned to serve local customers, students from nearby universities like Yale, travelers arriving at Tweed-New Haven Airport (HVN), and those in need of a temporary replacement vehicle.
Priceless of East Haven, which has been in the car rental business in the area since 1991, emphasizes providing value-conscious consumers with a diverse fleet of well-maintained vehicles. They are locally owned and operated, differentiating themselves from larger, corporately managed airport giants. The facility is also uniquely located inside a full-service repair facility with 24-hour towing, making it a comprehensive automotive hub for Central Connecticut drivers.
However, users should approach their booking with a clear understanding of the agency’s policies, as customer feedback reveals mixed experiences, particularly concerning insurance requirements. While some reviews, like one from satisfied out-of-state travelers, praise the "awesome" shuttle service and "great" staff who made the paperwork "easy," others warn of potential misunderstandings regarding insurance coverage. It is vital for all Connecticut customers—especially those booking through third-party sites—to contact the East Haven office directly beforehand to confirm their personal insurance meets all specific, non-negotiable coverage limits (often requiring high liability minimums and/or being pre-verified weeks in advance), or be prepared to purchase the agency's supplementary protection at the counter to avoid significant last-minute fees.
Ultimately, Priceless Car Rental aims to be the hometown choice for affordable car hire, provided the renter has meticulously verified all policy requirements before arrival to ensure a smooth, price-as-advertised transaction.
The East Haven location of Priceless Car Rental is highly accessible for drivers across the region and is conveniently situated near key Connecticut transportation hubs, making it an excellent choice for local users:
Address: 957 Foxon Rd, East Haven, CT 06513, USA. The office is situated right on Route 80 (Foxon Road), less than one mile from Exit 8 on Interstate 91. This positioning allows easy access to both I-95 and I-91, facilitating travel throughout Connecticut and New England.
Proximity to Airport: The location is conveniently close to the Tweed-New Haven Airport (HVN) and is known to offer a shuttle or pick-up service, making it a viable alternative for air travelers.
Local Pick-up/Drop-off: The agency typically offers local pick-up and drop-off in the surrounding area, a valuable convenience for customers whose personal vehicles are unavailable.
Physical Accessibility: The facility ensures ease of access for all customers, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
Priceless Car Rental in East Haven operates as a single type—a car rental agency—but offers a robust suite of services and vehicle options tailored to Central Connecticut's diverse needs. Their goal is to provide a vehicle for every customer, focusing on value and local convenience.
Diverse Vehicle Fleet: The local inventory varies but generally includes small economy cars perfect for city driving, mid-size and full-size sedans, spacious SUVs, minivans for families, and even larger passenger vans (like 15-passenger models) for group transport.
Insurance/Accident Rentals: They offer direct billing to insurance companies for customers needing a rental while their own car is in the shop for repairs.
Rentals for Students and Younger Drivers: They are known for offering rental options to students and drivers under 25, though these groups should expect specific age-related fees and mandatory insurance requirements, often including an underage surcharge (e.g., for ages 18-24).
Debit Card and Cash Rentals: The agency accepts both Credit cards and Debit cards for payment, a significant advantage for customers who prefer not to use a credit card. However, be advised that renting with a debit card will likely require a higher security deposit and may have additional strict requirements.
Courtesy Shuttle Service: For customers arriving from local transportation hubs, a courtesy shuttle service is generally offered (check for current hours and availability).
Long-Term Rentals and Car Sales: They also offer car sales (often former rentals) and long-term rental options, providing a flexible solution for multi-week or monthly needs.
While the affordable pricing is a major draw for the Priceless name, the East Haven branch offers several operational features that appeal to the local Connecticut market:
Locally Owned and Operated: The business has deep roots in East Haven since 1991, offering a personal touch and community-focused service that you may not find at large corporate hubs.
Integrated Automotive Service: Being located inside a full-service repair facility provides a unique benefit, as it ensures their rental fleet is well-maintained and provides customers with access to comprehensive automotive solutions, including 24-hour towing.
Affordable Rates: The primary value proposition is highly competitive and affordable daily rates, though this is heavily contingent on meeting all their specific insurance requirements.
Flexible Payment: Acceptance of major Credit cards and Debit cards caters to a broader range of the Connecticut population.
Clear Insurance Policy Requirement (Caveat Emptor): The business requires a specific level of personal auto liability insurance (often cited as $300k combined single limit) which must often be verified by a specific date prior to pickup. Failure to meet these exact, stringent requirements upon arrival will result in a mandatory purchase of their more expensive in-house coverage. Renters must fully understand and adhere to this policy to receive the quoted low rate.
For Connecticut customers, particularly those needing to verify insurance coverage or arrange a local pickup, it is highly recommended to call the office directly well in advance of the reservation date:
Address: 957 Foxon Rd, East Haven, CT 06513, USA
Phone: (203) 466-5315
Mobile Phone (Direct): +1 203-466-5315
Priceless Car Rental in East Haven is truly worth choosing for the Connecticut renter who prioritizes budget and local service, provided they heed the critical warnings regarding policies. The chief reasons to select this agency include its significantly affordable pricing and its long-standing status as a locally owned business in the New Haven area. Their fleet of economy, mid-size, and commercial vans offers genuine value for those moving items, taking a family trip, or needing an inexpensive commuter car.
The complimentary local pick-up and drop-off service is an invaluable feature, especially for residents who have brought their cars in for service or are flying into HVN. Additionally, the option to pay with a debit card expands accessibility to a wide audience who might not have a credit card available for rental deposits.
However, the key to a positive experience here lies in proactive communication. To avoid the hidden fees and complications reported by some customers who felt they were running an "insurance scam," Connecticut renters must call the agency days or weeks before pickup to verify that their personal insurance company, policy, and coverage levels (including the required $300k minimum liability) are explicitly acceptable under the terms of their reservation. By completing this verification step and securing a clear confirmation of acceptance, customers can fully enjoy the "easy paperwork" and "great staff" experience that other satisfied renters have received, securing a clean, affordable vehicle without any costly surprises.
Priceless Car Rental Details
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Priceless Car Rental Photos










Priceless Car Rental Location
Priceless Car Rental
957 Foxon Rd, East Haven, CT 06513, USA
Priceless Car Rental Reviews
airportpricesinsurancescamexpediabookfeespayphone30 minutes
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1SCAM SCAM SCAM - 0 Stars!Do not ever rent from this company - running a SCAM.They say that you need 100k-300k insurance coverage per incident when you book. We had 100k so figured it would be fine. We get there after the 25 minute car ride and 30 minute wait at the airport and the guy says we need 300k. I say no problem and am about to up it on my phone in the Allstate app and he says that won't work because it needs to be done 1 month in advance. At this point it is 11 pm, we have no other option but to just pay the $40 / day extra charge. we get over it.But when we go to return the car - a family is waiting for an Uber. They tell us that they called the day before to confirm their insurance was acceptable and were told it was. then when they arrive (after a 1hr + wait at the airport) they are told they need to purchase the $25/day extra insurance.The cars may rent for $5/day but they will get you in added and hidden fees and insurance scam.
August 27 · Aud CryanThey were awesome got us a shuttle from the airport. Easy paperwork and we were on our way. The staff was great! Thank you and we will definitely rent again. Dana and Jimmy-treasure island fl
May 23 · James PedersenUsed East Haven CT rental and we had no problems at all.The staff were nice and the check in and check out was easy. We will be using them again. We used the shuttle and had no problems. If you use the shuttle call when you land. It takes a good 20 minutes to pick you up
February 17 · RachelI have traveled tons of times over the years, and renting a car from Priceless was the WORST experience I have ever had while traveling. Do NOT use this company. We prepaid in full and had a confirmed reservation. But, when we arrived at Priceless, they had no cars available and had overbooked with about 50 angry people milling about who also were promised cars they didn't have. We were not given any information about how long we would have to wait or offered any accommodation whatsoever. When I heard that people there had already been waiting for hours, I explained that my kids were hungry and needed a meal and asked if we could walk next door to a restaurant to get food and then come back. We were told that if we left the rental office for any reason, our reservation would be canceled. We ended up having to wait five and a half hours with hungry, tired kids for a rental car.The worst part though was that when we finally finally got to the front of the line, Priceless took advantage of the situation they had put us in and would only rent us a car if we paid more than double the "full" price we had already pre-paid and added all sorts of fees and charges without any real explanation. They also informed us (for the first time, after waiting hours and hours at their office, and after standard business hours) that they would only accept our insurance if we were able to get our insurance agent on the phone right then and there to verbally verify our insurance coverage. The whole experience was terrible and felt very much like a scam.
January 02 · Jenn SPickup and drop off at airport was perfect. The car was very clean and the staff was very helpful and friendly. Definitely will use in the future.
April 18 · Margaret Coates
More Car Rental Near Me
Rent-A-Wreck4.0 (47 reviews)957 Foxon Rd, East Haven, CT 06513, USA
Mongoose Enterprise, LLC5.0 (10 reviews)299 Chapel St ste 47, New Haven, CT 06513, USA
Avis Car Rental2.0 (129 reviews)170 Olive St, New Haven, CT 06511, USA
Budget Car Rental2.0 (70 reviews)170 Olive St, New Haven, CT 06511, USA
Hertz Car Rental - New Haven - George Street2.0 (377 reviews)1 George St, New Haven, CT 06510, USA
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (183 reviews)389 State St, North Haven, CT 06473, USA
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (368 reviews)4 Liesl Ln, Branford, CT 06405, USA
Avis Car Rental3.0 (233 reviews)50 Union Ave, New Haven, CT 06519, USA
Hertz Car Rental - New Haven Amtrak Station - Union Avenue1.0 (11 reviews)50 Union Ave, New Haven, CT 06519, USA
Budget Car Rental3.0 (124 reviews)50 Union Ave, New Haven, CT 06519, USA
Avis Car Rental2.0 (133 reviews)155 Burr St, New Haven, CT 06512, USA
Rent-A-Wreck3.0 (17 reviews)1091 Dixwell Ave, Hamden, CT 06514, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (329 reviews)
BEST RENTALS INC3.0 (3 reviews)
Avis Car Rental3.0 (84 reviews)
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (482 reviews)
PV Fleet LLC0.0 (0 reviews)
Express Rent-A-Car3.0 (58 reviews)Trending Car Rental Blog Posts
How to Handle a Delayed or Canceled Flight When Your Rental Car Booking is Affected
What Every Driver Should Ask at the Rental Desk Before Signing the Agreement | LifeStar Car Rental
What Every Traveler Should Know About Vehicle Type Upgrades
How to Choose the Best Rental Car for Visiting U.S. Theme Parks, Water Parks & Family Resorts
7 Reasons to Book a Rental Car Instead of Using Ride-Share Apps
Renting a Car for a Road Trip: Best Routes, Vehicle Picks & Packing Tips | Lifestarcarrentalmn.com
