Rent A Car Introduce
For New Yorkers seeking a straightforward, reliable, and highly reviewed solution for both personal car rentals and utility truck needs, "Rent A Car" on Stillwell Avenue in Brooklyn offers a compelling local option. Unlike massive, impersonal airport rental hubs, this agency focuses on providing neighborhood-level service that is often essential for daily life in the city—whether you need a temporary vehicle while yours is in the shop, or a capable truck for a local move or work project.
The agency operates as a dual-purpose provider: a specialized Car Rental Agency and a Truck Rental Agency. This combination ensures they can meet diverse local demands, from a quick weekend escape to a sudden need for commercial hauling capacity. Furthermore, their fleet showcases a thoughtful mix of utility and modernity, including the rugged and practical Dodge RAM 1500 and the high-tech, increasingly popular Tesla Model 3, catering to a wide range of customer preferences and budgets.
Customer feedback is a significant highlight for Rent A Car. One future renter noted they were initially hesitant due to negative online comments but was "pleasantly surprised" by a "painless" process that earned the experience a virtual 10-star rating. Specific praise was directed at the professionalism and thoroughness of the staff, who confirmed fuel levels and existing damages before departure, alongside the genuinely clean condition of the vehicle. Another patron awarded a full five stars, commending the "top-notch" service, "impeccably clean and reliable" cars, and a management team that "went above and beyond" to deliver a seamless process. In a city where a clean, well-maintained rental can often be a rarity, this commitment to quality sets Rent A Car apart.
Location and Accessibility
Rent A Car is conveniently situated in the Gravesend/Coney Island area of South Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for residents of surrounding neighborhoods like Bensonhurst, Sheepshead Bay, and Brighton Beach.
Address: 2695 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA
Key access and operational details for New York users:
- Neighborhood Focus: The location on Stillwell Avenue places it directly within a densely populated residential and commercial section of Brooklyn, ideal for local customers.
- Transit Connectivity: The area is well-served by public transportation, particularly the D, F, and N subway lines, offering New Yorkers an easy transit option to pick up their rental without relying on taxis or ride-shares.
- Local Road Network: Stillwell Avenue provides straightforward access to major South Brooklyn thoroughfares, facilitating quick entry and exit from the neighborhood for those heading onto the Belt Parkway or towards other parts of the city or Long Island.
- Hours of Operation: Based on associated public data, the business operates with convenient weekday hours, typically from 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM, though customers should always confirm the latest schedule, especially for Saturday and Sunday availability, which may be closed or limited for certain services.
Services Offered
Rent A Car offers comprehensive vehicle solutions, specializing in both passenger and commercial-grade rentals for the local New York community.
- Car Rental Agency Services: Providing late-model, clean, and reliable passenger vehicles for daily, weekly, or extended personal use, including temporary replacements for vehicles undergoing repairs.
- Truck Rental Agency Services: Offering utility vehicles like the robust Dodge RAM 1500, perfect for hauling, moving, or heavy-duty work projects in the city and surrounding areas.
- Electric Vehicle Rental: Featuring the high-efficiency and popular Tesla Model 3 for eco-conscious renters or those seeking a modern driving experience.
- Variety of Payment Options: Accepts major forms of payment for flexibility, including both Credit Cards and Debit Cards, which is beneficial for New York residents who may prefer one method over the other for a security deposit and rental fees.
- Seamless Pick-up and Drop-off: The agency strives to ensure a quick and "painless" rental process, minimizing wait times and maximizing efficiency—a crucial factor for busy New Yorkers.
Features and Highlights
The local business distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New York rental market by focusing on vehicle quality, transparent pricing, and exceptional customer service.
- Cleanliness and Maintenance: Customer reviews repeatedly emphasize that the cars are "impeccably clean" and free from unpleasant odors, reflecting a high standard of vehicle upkeep.
- Modern Fleet Selection: The availability of the practical Dodge RAM 1500 ($125.00 daily) and the cutting-edge Tesla Model 3 ($175.00 daily) demonstrates a commitment to offering relevant and high-demand vehicle types.
- Transparent Transaction Process: Staff are noted for their professionalism in recording existing damages and fuel levels accurately at the start of the rental, ensuring customers are not unfairly charged upon return.
- Customer-Centric Management: The management team is highlighted for going "above and beyond" to ensure a positive and seamless rental experience, focusing on clear communication and readiness of the reserved vehicle.
- Flexible Payment Options: Acceptance of both credit and debit cards makes the service accessible to a broader range of the local clientele.
Contact Information
For reservations, current pricing, and confirmation of specific vehicle availability, New York renters should contact the Brooklyn office directly.
Phone: (718) 265-5975
Mobile Phone: +1 718-265-5975
Address: 2695 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA
What is worth choosing this local Brooklyn operation over a large, impersonal chain comes down to service quality, vehicle condition, and a personalized experience. In New York, where time is money and reliability is paramount, the exceptional cleanliness of the vehicles and the management's proactive commitment to a "seamless rental process" are invaluable. The availability of specialized vehicles—a reliable pickup truck for utility and a Tesla for those who want to experience electric driving in the city or on a trip upstate—ensures that customers don't have to compromise on their needs. The glowing customer reviews, which specifically overcome initial skepticism about local agencies, strongly indicate that Rent A Car delivers on its promises of professionalism and quality, making it a highly reliable choice for Brooklyn residents.
Rent A Car Services
Car Rental Agency
- Dodge RAM 1500 $125.00
Full-Size Pick up Truck
- Tesla Model 3 $175.00
Rent A Car Details
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Rent A Car Photos










Rent A Car Location
Rent A Car
2695 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA
Rent A Car Reviews
pricedrivingphonetruckdepositmoneychoicesmelldamages
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Good morning future renters. please take those negative reviews, on this business, with a huge grain of salt! I read them and almost cancelled my reservation. Fortunately, I decided to move forward. I picked up my rental yesterday and the process was painless. If it were an option, I would give them 10 stars! My vehicle is currently in the shop for repairs and I need something for work and everyday running around. I notified them of my eta and upon arrival I was greeted, welcomed into the office and they let me know that my rental was ready. Next, they checked my ID and I signed the contract. I was escorted outside, the gentleman recorded the amount of fuel, confirmed that there was windshield washer fluid, checked for any existing damages and I was on my way. I sat in the car for a moment to adjust the seat, mirrors and connect my phone and realized that there was no awful smell and the car was exceptionally clean. I had become so accustomed to rentals being gross and grungy, so I was pleasantly surprised. Stay tuned, I'll post an update about the entire experience when I return the vehicle.
March 06 · Allison Abdul-WahabI had an exceptional experience with Rent a Car! The service was top-notch, the cars were impeccably clean and reliable. The management team went above and beyond to ensure a seamless rental process. Five stars for an outstanding service that exceeded my expectations!
December 15 · Alan MamedovI cannot stress enough how disappointing my experience was with this car rental company. From the start, it was a series of broken promises and poor service.First, the deposit issue was a nightmare. They promised a quick and easy return of my deposit, but weeks later, I’m still waiting. Every time I call, I get vague excuses and zero follow-through. It feels like they’re just trying to hold onto my money for as long as possible.Then there’s the issue of the car itself. The vehicle I received was poorly maintained. It was dirty, with visible wear and tear, and it made strange noises during my drive. I had serious doubts about its safety, and I didn’t feel comfortable taking it on longer trips.Additionally, when I brought up these concerns to their customer service, they were dismissive and unhelpful. They promised to assist me with maintenance issues and never followed through. It was incredibly frustrating dealing with a company that doesn’t prioritize customer satisfaction.Overall, my experience was a complete letdown. Unprofessional service, unfulfilled promises, and poorly maintained cars are a recipe for disaster.
October 30 · AndrewI had an absolutely terrible experience with this car rental company and would never recommend them to anyone. They seemed determined to make a profit at our expense, regardless of the quality of service.First, the car they initially gave us broke down shortly after we started driving, leaving us stranded and having to wait for assistance and made all work day messed up. The replacement car they provided was old and poorly maintained. When we complained, they reluctantly offered a third car, which was barely acceptable – but only if you don’t mind a car that feels like it’s on its last legs.To make things worse, they didn’t returned our deposit since 3 weeks we returned the car: there where no tickets; no violations; no damages.Moreover, they gave us very dirty car and we washed it for our expenses. We’re sure that our insurance must have covered a better options cars, but they still tried to made money on us for the inconvenience of using old, unreliable vehicles. This was hands down the worst rental experience I’ve ever had, and I strongly advise anyone to look elsewhere if they value their money and peace of mind.I wish I could put 0 stars.
October 30 · Daria TkachukI recently had a fantastic experience with Always Amore! The staff was friendly, and made the entire rental process a breeze. The car selection was good, and the vehicle I chose was clean and well-maintained.I highly recommend Always Amore for anyone in need of reliable car rental services. They've earned my trust, and I'll definitely choose them. 5 stars all the way!
December 13 · Vladimir Winecoor
More Car Rental Near Me
WHEELZ 4 RENT3.0 (4 reviews)2695 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA
Rent2Ride Corp4.0 (12 reviews)2753 Harway Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA
Izcarplug5.0 (5 reviews)209 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Drivo Rent A Car4.0 (960 reviews)3221 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
ACE Rent A Car4.0 (730 reviews)3221 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (656 reviews)2815 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Act Ambulette Brooklyn4.0 (6 reviews)1411 Gravesend Neck Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
King NY5.0 (2 reviews)1429 Shore Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA
Golden Age Ambulette Inc3.0 (36 reviews)1805 Gravesend Neck Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
Cathay Express Transportation4.0 (6 reviews)7602 21st Ave #3m, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA
Wheelchair Transportation5.0 (2 reviews)1804 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
Grand luxury Rental5.0 (75 reviews)2219 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Legendary Exotic Auto Rentals4.0 (18 reviews)
Hertz Car Rental - Johnstown Cambria Airport3.0 (34 reviews)
Cathay Express Transportation5.0 (4 reviews)
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (156 reviews)
Enterprise Rent-A-Car4.0 (639 reviews)
We Can Help Auto Rentals5.0 (37 reviews)Trending Car Rental Blog Posts
Renting a Car for a Road Trip: Best Routes, Vehicle Picks & Packing Tips | Lifestarcarrentalmn.com
What Rental Car Companies Don’t Tell You About Insurance Coverage
How Seasonal Events (e.g., Sports Games, Concerts) Impact Rental Car Availability & Rates
Tips for Veteran Drivers Renting Cars After Military Service
Why Airport Car Rentals Are Always More Expensive — and When They’re Worth It
How to Choose the Best Rental Car for Visiting U.S. Theme Parks, Water Parks & Family Resorts
